Scott Preston’s debut novel, “The Borrowed Hills,” has taken the literary world by storm. Published in April 2024, the book has garnered critical acclaim for its unique blend of genres, compelling characters, and its stark portrayal of rural life in northern England. This article delves into the world of “The Borrowed Hills,” exploring its plot, characters, themes, and the reasons behind its success.

A Desperate Heist in the Shadow of the Fells
The story unfolds in the harsh and unforgiving landscape of the Cumbrian Fells, a mountainous region in northwest England. “The Borrowed Hills” is a neo-Western, a subgenre that transplants the classic Western tropes of cowboys, outlaws, and moral ambiguity to a non-American setting. Here, the cowboys are sheep farmers, their livelihood threatened by a devastating outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease. This real-world crisis, which ravaged British agriculture in 2001, forms the backdrop of the novel.
Our protagonist, Steve Elliman, returns to his family farm after years away to help his aging father. Witnessing the destruction of their flock by government culling measures leaves them on the brink of financial ruin. Desperate for survival, Steve and his friend, Tom, embark on a daring and dangerous plan: to steal sheep from a wealthy landowner in the south of England. This high-stakes heist forms the central plot point of the novel, driving the narrative forward with a thrilling sense of tension.
A World of Grit and Resilience: Characters Driven to Desperation
The characters in “The Borrowed Hills” are not your typical heroes. They are flawed individuals, shaped by the harsh realities of their environment. Steve, the narrator, grapples with a troubled past and a fierce loyalty to his family and his way of life. Tom, his accomplice, is a complex figure, harboring a deep-seated resentment towards the wealthy elite.
The novel doesn’t shy away from portraying the harsh realities of rural poverty. Farming is a demanding and unforgiving profession, and the characters in the novel are constantly battling against the elements and economic pressures. This struggle for survival adds a layer of authenticity to the story and makes the characters all the more relatable.
However, “The Borrowed Hills” is not simply a bleak depiction of rural hardship. There is also a strong sense of community and resilience among the farmers. They rely on each other for support, and they fiercely defend their traditions and way of life. This sense of community adds depth to the story and creates a sense of empathy for the characters, even when they are driven to desperate measures.
Beyond the Heist: A Story of Loss, Love, and Legacy
While the sheep heist is the central plot point, “The Borrowed Hills” explores a range of themes that resonate with readers. The novel grapples with the loss of tradition – the decline of small-scale farming in the face of modernization and corporate agriculture. It explores the complex relationships between fathers and sons, and the lengths people will go to protect their families. Love, both familial and romantic, also plays a significant role, offering a glimmer of hope amidst the harsh realities of the story.
Preston’s lyrical prose brings the rugged beauty of the Cumbrian Fells to life. He captures the harshness of the terrain, the unforgiving weather, and the stark beauty of the landscape. The natural world becomes a character in itself, reflecting the struggles and resilience of the human characters.
Critical Acclaim and Reader Response
“The Borrowed Hills” has received glowing reviews from critics around the world. Praised for its “uncompromising vision” and “stunning debut,” the novel has been compared to the works of Cormac McCarthy and Annie Proulx. Readers have been captivated by the story’s gritty realism, its complex characters, and its unique blend of genres.
On Goodreads, the novel boasts a rating of 3.93 stars, with many readers praising the book’s “dark, cinematic” atmosphere and its “breathtaking” heist plot. Several reviewers have highlighted the novel’s ability to transport them to the remote beauty of the Cumbrian Fells.
“The Borrowed Hills” is more than just a thrilling crime novel; it’s a compelling exploration of rural life, family bonds, and the fight for survival. With its unforgettable characters, evocative setting, and exploration of universal themes, the novel is sure to resonate with readers for years to come.

FAQ’S
What genre is The Borrowed Hills?
The Borrowed Hills falls under contemporary fiction, with strong elements of literary fiction and a touch of thriller.
Where is The Borrowed Hills set?
The story unfolds in the rugged landscape of Cumbria, northwest England. The harsh beauty of the fells (hills) plays a significant role in shaping the characters’ lives and struggles.
What is The Borrowed Hills about?
The story centers around two sheep farmers, Steve Elliman and William Herne, whose lives are devastated by a fictional outbreak of foot and mouth disease. The government enforces a cull, destroying their flocks and livelihoods. The novel explores their desperation, resilience, and the choices they make to survive.
Who is the main character in The Borrowed Hills?
Steve Elliman serves as the main narrator, offering a firsthand perspective on the crisis and its impact on him and his community. However, William Herne is another crucial character whose actions and motivations drive the plot forward.
Are there any real-life events that inspired The Borrowed Hills?
The novel draws inspiration from the real-life foot and mouth disease outbreak that crippled the British farming industry in 2001. Preston captures the despair and economic devastation the event caused, weaving it into a fictional narrative.
What are some of the themes explored in The Borrowed Hills?
The novel delves into themes of human resilience in the face of adversity, the struggle to maintain a traditional way of life, the moral complexities of survival, and the deep connection between people and the land.
How has The Borrowed Hills been received by critics?
Critics have praised the novel for its raw, visceral prose, its well-developed characters, and its unflinching portrayal of a rural community in crisis. Comparisons have been drawn to authors like Cormac McCarthy and William Faulkner for the stark realism and gritty atmosphere.
Are there any reviews available online for The Borrowed Hills?
Yes, you can find reviews from various publications and readers on sites like BookBrowse [invalid URL removed] and The Times Literary Supplement [invalid URL removed].
Is The Borrowed Hills available for purchase?
Yes, The Borrowed Hills is available in hardcover, paperback, and ebook formats from major retailers.
Is there an audiobook version of The Borrowed Hills?
While information on an audiobook version is currently unavailable, it’s always worth checking online retailers or contacting the publisher for updates.
Will there be a sequel to The Borrowed Hills?
There is no official announcement about a sequel at this time. However, the critical success of the novel might pave the way for further exploration of this world or characters by the author.
Can I find out more about Scott Preston, the author?
Unfortunately, there isn’t a lot of information available online about Scott Preston at this point. You can keep an eye out for author interviews or updates from the publisher for more details.
To read more, Click here